EU doesn't quite understand morals | Featured |Axisoflogic.com

Editor's Commentary:

It seems like forever that people have been protesting against the seal hunt in Canada. Although it is always couched by the Canadian government that this is destructive to the livelihood of Aboriginal hunters, the fact is that protesters have never objected to Indigenous Peoples making a living from hunting seals. What they have argued against is the onslaught of brutal hunters, many not from Canada, who tend to club baby seals to a painful death in order to ensure that the pelts are marketable.

After long struggles, the European Union finally banned the import of Canadian seal products. And they did so, they said, on 'moral' grounds. The initial decision has withstood multiple court and trade body appeals by Canada, and the EU can justifiably be proud of taking a principled stand.

So contrast that with the story covered in Ms Lazare's article below. Despite all the evidence of global climate change, and all the evidence of the filth and environmental disaster that is inherent in Canada's tar sands, the EU seems poised to give Canada free range to spread this muck around the world.

Ms Lazare's article first appeared on Common Dreams, and one of the readers who commented on her piece, Jonny James, wrote this:

The European Commission is the epitome of an unaccountable group of industry lobbyists, former industry CEOs and the "revolving door" of private/public officials. The Commission is not elected nor accountable to the public.

The EU system of governance suffers from a severe "democratic deficit". While open borders and a lack of warfare between France and Germany is great, much of the rest of the EU project is destroying what is left of 'social democracy' and turning Europe into a kleptocratic oligarchy.

The European Central Bank (ECB), is another unaccountable institution that wields dictatorial powers over monetary policy. They are a consortium of private mega-banks, dominated by Germany.

In short, the EU is basically a neoliberal project to hijack economic and financial policy and give control to an unaccountable network of corporations and banks.

Exactly.

As you can see from the photo below, there is good reason that people refer to this part of Alberta as 'Fort McMordor'. [If you're not a Lord of Rings fan, look it up.]

- prh, Editor
Axis of Logic

Tar sands in Alberta (Photo: Howl Arts Collective / Flickr Creative Commons)

After years of lobbying to break into European markets, Canada's tar sands oil industry is poised to score a victory from EU lawmakers who have signaled willingness to drop a requirement that labels tar sands oil as dirtier than other fossil fuels.

The EU agreed five years ago to a piece of climate legislation called the 'Fuel Quality Directive,' which was to go into effect in 2010 with the aim of cutting transport fuel emissions by 6 percent by 2020. Yet thanks to heavy industry lobbying and government stalling, the plan still has not gone into effect years later.

Both the Financial Times and Reuters reported Thursday that the EU is likely to weaken the language of the not-yet-implemented plan by scrapping a requirement that bitumen—oil extracted from tar sands—be labeled as high-emissions diesel. The higher rating would have discouraged, but not prevented, imports.

A draft document drawn up by the European Commission will, if implemented, allow companies to sidestep penalties on tar sands imports. "Under the new methodology, companies would only have to make their emission cuts based on EU averages for the 'output' fuels – the petrol or diesel – regardless of whether it was originally made from heavy crude or not," the Financial Times explains.

One of the world's dirtiest fossil fuels, bitumen produces up to five times more carbon than conventional crude oil. The extraction process is extremely energy-intensive, destructive to ecosystems, and creates large reservoirs of toxic waste. Environmental groups have argued that proposed regulations in previous drafts of the Fuel Quality Directive were already too lax, and that tar sands should simply stay in the ground.

The government of Canada and the oil industry have aggressively opposed potential EU penalties on bitumen imports, and Canada's Natural Resources Minister pressed the issue in sideline conversations at the G7 meetings in Rome last month, according to Reuters.

Meanwhile, environmental protesters rallied this week against what is believed to be the first large shipment of bitumen to Europe, which arrived in Spain from Canada.

"Tar sands are deadly for our climate and must be kept in the ground and out of Europe," said Colin Roche of Friends of the Earth in a statement about the delivery. "To give a lifeline to this dangerous industry is to set us up for climate disaster."

Source URL